Main content start

Thomas Paine in Revolutionary France: The Age of Reason and the Politics of Natural Religion

Speaker
Heath Rojas, Postdoctoral Scholar, Stanford Civics Initiative
Date
Fri November 6th 2026, 11:30am - 1:00pm
Location
Encina Hall West, Room 417
Abstract
In this paper, I trace the development of Thomas Paine’s deistic thought across his years in Revolutionary France, taking The Age of Reason as a starting point rather than as a finished statement of his religious worldview. Although Paine completed the first part of The Age of Reason in 1793, just before his imprisonment in Paris, the work offered relatively little account of what a positive deistic life might look like in practice. While interpretations of Paine have often emphasized his debts to British freethought, they have likewise tended to foreground the critical and deconstructive dimensions of his writings on theology, especially his attacks on revealed religion. I argue, in contrast, that his longer experience of the French Revolution became increasingly important to the evolution of his beliefs, bringing him into direct contact with experiments in revolutionary deism and prompting him to consider more fully how deistic faith might take institutional and communal form. I first situate The Age of Reason within Paine’s French years and then examine his later writings, especially his engagement with Theophilanthropy—a movement founded under the Directory that sought to make deism into a lived religion. I also reconstruct the French and transatlantic networks in which Paine moved, including his relationships with Joel Barlow and Nicolas Bonneville, to recover the intellectual exchanges through which his ideas continued to change. These experiences, I suggest, helped Paine think more concretely about forms of religious association grounded in nature and divine creation rather than scriptural or ecclesiastical authority, as well as whether such a faith could cultivate civic virtue while remaining compatible with republican freedom. Drawing on recently recovered writings, now available in the sixth volume of Thomas Paine: Collected Writings, I reassess this later phase of Paine’s intellectual development before examining how publishers in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries repackaged The Age of Reason alongside other texts that gave fuller expression to his deistic commitments. I conclude with the work’s contentious reception in the early United States, where polemical responses often obscured the broader religious and political vision that emerged from Paine’s years in revolutionary France.
Biography
Heath Rojas a historian of early modern Europe and the Atlantic world, with a primary focus on France. His research examines faith and politics in the Enlightenment and the Age of Revolutions. More broadly, His work explores the role of affect and the sacred in modern political life. His book project focuses on “sentimental deism,” a form of natural religion that privileged moral sentiment, alongside reason, as a means of apprehending God and cultivating virtue. He traces this tradition from early modern debates over the passions and natural theology through Rousseau and the French Revolution. In doing so, he argues that new understandings of human emotion profoundly shaped deistic belief and worship. Spanning Europe and the early United States, the project also investigates how the French Revolution’s efforts to remake religion crossed national and confessional boundaries through figures such as Thomas Paine and Joel Barlow. Heath held fellowships at the Library Company of Philadelphia, the Hagley Museum and Library, and Columbia’s Institute for Religion, Culture and Public Life. Additionally, his research has been supported by Harvard’s Houghton Library, Dartmouth’s Rauner Special Collections, the Connecticut Museum of Culture and History, the Massachusetts Historical Society, the Congregational Library & Archives, and the Vermont Historical Society. His other awards include the Georges Lurcy Fellowship for Research in France, the Jerrold Seigel Fellowship in Intellectual and Cultural History, and the Laurie M. Wood Award from the Society for French Historical Studies. Heath received his PhD in History from Columbia University in 2026 and hold AB degrees from Stanford University in History, with honors and distinction, and in French.